Case:
Nature's Blend Pty Ltd v Nestle Australia Ltd [2010] FCAFC 117
Judges: Stone, Gordon and McKerracher JJ
Headnote
Whether or not use of a trade mark has the necessary characteristics to qualify for a finding of infringement must be tested with reference to the context in which it is used. That context includes such factors as style, size, location and the presence of other more prominent trade marks,
Introduction
In my post of
24 March 2010, I reported on the decision of a single judge of the Federal Court in connection with this dispute. That court found that the use of the words "luscious lips" in a blurb that appeared on the back of a package was not use of those words as a trade mark. The judge was influenced by the fact that the package already showed both "Allen's" and "Nestle" in a prominent manner that indicated that they were being used as trade marks, thus diluting the effect of "luscious lips" as it appeared in relatively small type together with a number of other names on the back of the package.
In this case, the Full Federal Court said that the primary judge was correct and therefore that there was no infringement.